Skip to main content

A risk assessment scores each risk you have identified for impact and likelihood, each on a scale of 1 to 5, multiplies the two to get the risk’s exposure, and plots that score on a heat map so you can see at a glance which risks need urgent action, which just need monitoring, and which need no action at all. The same exercise, repeated after controls are in place, gives the residual risk. Everything is then recorded in a risk register: the objective at risk, the risk itself, its source, the indicators that warn you it could happen, the two scores, the mitigation plan and who owns it.

Key points

  • Risk assessment is the step after risk identification: it scores each risk for impact and likelihood, 1 to 5 on each, and multiplies them to get the risk’s exposure.
  • The heat map turns that score into a severity and an action: acceptable and no action needed, acceptable but monitor, significant and needs mitigation, unacceptable and needs urgent action, or catastrophic enough to stop the activity.
  • Inherent risk is the score before any control; residual risk is the score after. Inherent risk does not change; residual risk should fall as mitigation improves.
  • A full assessment records more than a number: the objective at risk, the underlying value at risk, the source of the risk, and the indicators that tell you it could materialise.
  • Everything is documented in a risk register, with the mitigation plan, the person responsible, a target date and the current status.

What risk assessment is, and where it fits

Risk assessment comes after you have identified a risk. It is the systematic process of recognising and characterising a risk and then evaluating how significant it is, so that management can decide how to manage it: risk identification, risk analysis and risk evaluation. Risk monitoring is a separate, ongoing step that follows, once the assessment and the mitigation plan are in place.

The output of a risk assessment is a score or rating for each risk, usually shown as a position on a heat map. Take a simple example from the course: a company stores goods worth 100 million in a warehouse, and there is a risk of fire. Risk assessment asks two questions about that risk: what is the financial impact if the fire occurs, and how likely is it to occur. Everything else in this article builds on those two questions.

Scoring impact and likelihood

Both impact and likelihood are rated on the same 1-to-5 scale, then multiplied to give the risk a score out of 25.

Score Impact Likelihood
1 Negligible impact Improbable – hardly likely to occur
2 Very low impact Remote chance that it occurs
3 Moderate impact Occasional – has happened a few times from past experience
4 Significant impact Good probability – the chance is high
5 Catastrophic impact Frequent – keeps happening every now and then

In the warehouse example, if the likelihood of a fire is scored 3 and the impact is scored 5, the exposure is 3 × 5 = 15. That number is what gets plotted on the heat map.

Reading the heat map

The heat map plots impact against likelihood and groups the resulting scores into zones, each with its own required action. The course uses five zones:

Zone What it means What you do
Dark green The desirable state of risk No action needed
Light green Acceptable, risk levels are low Still monitor it
Yellow Undesirable, the risk is significant Take action so the risk moves back towards green
Amber Unacceptable Urgent action to mitigate the risk
Catastrophic The risk is both highly likely and severe Stop the activity until the risk is brought down; do not pursue the objective as things stand

Back to the warehouse: if the likelihood of fire were a 5 (fires happen there frequently) and the impact stays a 5 (100 million at stake), the score is 5 × 5 = 25 — the catastrophic zone. At that point the course’s advice is blunt: stop storing goods at that warehouse immediately, because both how often the fire risk occurs and what it would cost are too high to accept.

The same risk is not equally severe for every organisation. A warehouse fire is a major risk for a company that stores chemicals, where the impact is very high, but it may be only a moderate or low risk for a garment business storing the same value of less hazardous stock. What is being stored, not just its value, affects the impact score.

Risk assessment, step by step

Scoring impact and likelihood is the visible output, but a proper assessment works through several questions for each risk before it reaches that score:

  1. What is the objective? Start from the business objective the risk threatens, not from the risk in isolation.
  2. What is the risk, and what is the underlying value at risk? For the warehouse, the value at risk is the stock stored there.
  3. What is the source of the risk? For a fire, the source could be inflammable material stored on site, workers smoking near stock, or even construction in an adjoining unit that could short an electrical cable or throw a spark.
  4. What are the indicators? An indicator is information that tells you the risk could materialise: storing inflammable material is itself an indicator, as is a track record of fires at similar sites. If 8 of 10 similar warehouses have caught fire, the other 2 are flagged as being at risk too.
  5. What is the likelihood? Based on past experience: is the event frequent, occasional, or rare? Existing safeguards (sprinklers, fire detection, auto-extinguishing systems) lower the likelihood score.
  6. What is the overall consequence? Go wider than the direct loss. A warehouse fire does not just destroy stock and put people at risk; it can disrupt order processing, hit sales and damage the company’s reputation. All of this belongs in the consequence, not just the stock value.
  7. Document it in a risk register. The output of every one of these questions, for every risk, is recorded centrally (see the table below).

Worked example: the warehouse fire, start to finish

This is the course’s own illustration, used to show the method; it is not a real client.

  • Objective: keep finished-goods stock safe until it is shipped.
  • Risk: fire at the warehouse.
  • Value at risk: stock worth 100 million held at that location.
  • Source: inflammable material on site, and the possibility of workers smoking near stock.
  • Indicators: inflammable material is stored there; other warehouses of a similar type and age have a history of fires.
  • Likelihood: scored 3 out of 5 (occasional) in the base case, based on past experience at similar sites.
  • Impact: scored 5 out of 5 (catastrophic), because the full 100 million could be lost, plus risk to the people working there.
  • Inherent exposure: 3 × 5 = 15 — in the yellow/amber range, needing action.
  • Consequence, more widely: beyond the stock itself, a fire would disrupt order processing, affect sales and damage the company’s reputation.

Inherent risk vs residual risk

The same two scores, impact and likelihood, are used twice for every risk:

Inherent risk Residual risk
When it is measured Before any mitigation measures or controls are in place After the mitigation measures or controls have been implemented
Does it change? No — it stays as the raw level of risk Yes — it should fall as controls are implemented and improved, and is monitored over time
Warehouse example A brand-new warehouse, with stock stored before any fire-safety measures are installed The same warehouse once fire extinguishers are in place and staff are trained not to smoke near stock — the likelihood (and sometimes the impact) score falls

As an internal auditor your job is to assess how effective the mitigation measures (controls) actually are, because that effectiveness is what determines the residual risk. This is also where risk assessment hands off to the risk and control matrix: each risk in the register becomes a row, and the controls meant to reduce it are tested there.

What goes in a risk register

A risk register is where every risk you have assessed is documented, so it can be tracked and acted on. The course’s format records:

Column What goes in it
Objective The business objective the organisation is pursuing
Risk The risk identified against that objective
Risk category Financial, compliance, reputational or strategic (or another category that fits)
Indicators What tells you the risk could materialise, used for ongoing monitoring
Inherent risk assessment Impact, likelihood and the resulting exposure, before mitigation
Control activities The mitigation measures the business has put in place
Residual risk assessment Impact, likelihood and the resulting exposure, after mitigation
Mitigation plan The action points still to be taken
Responsible person Who owns the action, for example the storekeeper or logistics head in the warehouse example
Target date When the action point is due
Status Effective, ineffective, implemented or not implemented

For the warehouse, the mitigation plan’s action points might be: install fire extinguishers, and train staff not to smoke where stock is kept. The inherent risk assessment is filled in once and does not change; the residual risk assessment, the control activities and the status are updated as the mitigation measures are put in place and as the auditor tests whether they are adequate and effective.

▶ Watch it explained

Short videos from our internal audit course. Each one covers a single topic, step by step.

📄 Get the template

Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) Process: Risk and Control Matrix (Excel). 23 controls (19 key) for 7 objectives and 7 risks covering the ERM process itself: risk policy and governance, identification, appetite and tolerance, the risk register, mitigation plans and reporting to the risk committee, audit committee and board. Each control comes with walkthrough questions, evidence to ask for and test steps.

✅ Test yourself

Questions from our course quizzes. Click a question to see the answer.

Which of these is NOT part of the risk assessment process itself: risk identification, risk analysis, risk evaluation, or risk monitoring?

Risk monitoring. Risk assessment covers identification, analysis and evaluation; monitoring is the ongoing step that follows once the assessment and mitigation plan are in place. The output of the assessment is usually shown on a heat map.

While assessing a risk, which of these does management NOT normally analyse: the objective, the indicators of the risk, the impact of the risk, or the company’s revenue?

The company’s revenue. Management looks at the objective at risk, what is at risk, its source, the indicators, the likelihood and the consequences if it materialises — not the company’s overall revenue figure.

How is inherent risk defined?

The risk before any mitigation measures or controls have been implemented, measured by the raw impact and likelihood. Residual risk is the risk that remains after controls are in place, measured by the revised impact and likelihood once those controls are working.

Frequently asked questions

What is risk assessment in internal audit?

Risk assessment is the step after a risk has been identified: scoring it for impact and likelihood, each on a scale of 1 to 5, multiplying the two, and placing the result on a heat map to decide how significant the risk is and what action it needs.

What is a risk heat map?

A heat map plots impact against likelihood and groups the resulting scores into zones, from a desirable state needing no action, through zones that need monitoring or mitigation, up to a catastrophic zone where the activity should stop until the risk is brought down.

What is the difference between inherent risk and residual risk?

Inherent risk is the impact and likelihood score before any controls are applied; it does not change. Residual risk is the score after controls are in place and should fall as the controls improve. Both are recorded in the risk register.

What is a risk register?

A risk register documents every risk that has been assessed: the objective it threatens, the risk, its category, the indicators used to monitor it, the inherent and residual risk scores, the control activities in place, and a mitigation plan with an owner, a target date and a status.

Who is responsible for assessing risk?

Management identifies and assesses risk and puts mitigation measures in place. The internal auditor’s role is to assess whether those controls are adequate and effective, which is what determines the residual risk.

Related reading: The internal audit process, step by step · RCM example for accounts payable (step by step) · Internal control explained: COSO framework and examples

Zehra Maccawala

Author Zehra Maccawala

Zehra Maccawala (ACA, CIA) is a co-founder of Learn Internal Audit and a partner at ZMAS and Associates, a Chartered Accountancy firm specialising in internal audit. She has more than 20 years of experience evaluating business processes and conducting risk-focused operational and financial audits.

More posts by Zehra Maccawala

Leave a Reply